Seriously, think about it.
This is perhaps the main reason (white) social justice activists, be it on tumblr or in real life sketch me out. The very use of the word “justice” in this way gives me pause. What good is social justice in a society where justice has been systematically defined and enacted so as to favor the dominate ideology, only siding with the marginalized when the gulf between principle and practice becomes to large to simply rationalize or ignore?
Social justice would seem to be nothing more than a way to ‘philosophize disgrace’ and prevent the revolutionary destruction of the social order which uses its justice as a tool to oppress and marginalize
I didn’t even think of it that way, but you’re right. Justice has been notoriously used to refer to the spoils gained by the winner, hasn’t it?
So where does it go from here?
I think the first thing is that it needs a new turn of phrase.
Instead of “Social Justice”, let’s call it “Social Upturning”. I thought of “Uprooting” at first, but that sounds too violent.
I actually like uprooting because it sounds violent. Because I think that’s necessary. White people play that language game, let’s take them to task on OUR rules.
If my opinion as an uprootee isn’t intrusive…
Uprooting really feels like a really evocative description to me, compared to “upturning”. It’s not as easy flipping over a table (what “upturning” calls to mind), it sounds like you’re fighting something deep and entrenched with a lot of little tiny branches. If you just chop down the obvious growth on the surface, it’ll grow right back, and even if you attack the root it’s hard to know you killed it.
And from the point of view of people brought up in whiteness: “uprooting” in the figurative sense is what it takes. We have to be removed from that element of our upbringing, or remove it from ourselves.
Once again, AE reads my mind, cause this is the other reason I liked it so much. Tree-trimming at racism is what white people have been doing. They cut a couple of branches and go “hey look at what we’re doing, isn’t that nice?” But everyone knows when you don’t get the root of the weed, it just comes back.
![[Image: A gif of actress Gina Torres, a beautiful Black Latina, speaking and gesturing to illustrate her point.]
fuckyeahginatorres:
When I became an actress I quickly realize that the world liked their latinos to look Italian. Not like me. So I wasn’t going up for Latina parts. I was going up for African American parts. […] Regardless of the fact that I spoke the language better and understood the culture better, those weren’t the parts that…I could take seriously. Suddenly you have to explain why I look how I look. And then it gets complicated. And nobody wants complicated.
Gina Torres | Black & Latino](http://28.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lyhmp3yMN41qh1240o1_r4_500.gif)